sonny is not taking his medication with that bat crap crazy suggestion

[tollyfan35]

lets give up the romantic side of marriage and live under one roof while raising avery and donna yeah sonny that won't confuse donna and avery at all

[OLTLBoomer]

I agree on the confusion, however I do believe that Sonny is taking his meds and is trying to salvage his marriage and family - hence the suggestion of co-habitation in the Compound. Carly called him on the adultery and the confusion of the children, and that the children will be hurt no matter what they do, as it will not be a loving home setting.

side note - this stands to work out well for Ava, as Carly said, she gets Donna, but no mention of Avery.

[Bobaloo]

Good for Carly for shooting that down quickly and decisively. She was absolutely right that subjecting the girls to a farce would be more harmful than helping them adjust to visiting one parent in another location. Avery already understands this by visiting Ava, and Donna will adjust. It's better than forcing them to watch their parents cohabitate with anger and agitation towards each other.

[Laura Luke]

I would like to see Donna & Avery with Ava so they can get more time together

[december rose]

Why should Ava get Donna at all?

[DayRose]

Go Carly! I'm glad she's focusing on what's best for the girls and didn't fall for Sonny's stupid suggestion. Hopefully Avery will be able to visit Donna and Carly at the house so the sisters stay close.

[taramartin]

When he suggested it, I thought - oh, this is a soapy way to reunite them - but no not happening.

[december rose]

Me too. Cause I'm sure Sonny believes that Carly will not be able to resist him long term

[believeinme246]

To me, Carson always worked better as divorced co-parents who went on with their own lives. I like them each better with other people, and I thought that the Carly Jax marriage provided what was the healthiest time for the children.

Besides, why would anyone want to stymie the rest of their lives and love lives by living together in a romance-free relationship. That's pretty grim, and doesn't teach the children at all about healthy relationships.

[lala214]

I disagree. Sonny still wants to save the marriage. That was his last ditch effort to do so. Carly was never interested in "saving" or "fixing" the marriage so she refused.

[mslove83]

Maybe if Sonny would have told the full truth a couple of months earlier his wife wouldn’t have been blindsided and needed space to wrap her head around things.

[Shellyinphx]

And if Sonny had actually given carly 5 minutes to work through his romance with nina instead of spending so much time with nina he'd still have his marriage

[lala214]

Maybe if Carly had actually been interested in her marriage and wasn't so self-centered, they'd be together but she wasn't so they aren't.

[Emerald Greens]

He seems to forget Avery has a mother that is not Carly. I actually appreciate that Carly cares about Avery so it’s not about that.
Sonny was making it about himself it’s what he wants . He wants to present a lie to the girls to try and get back in Carly’s good graces. Children adjust all the time to situations like this and grow up fine as Carly said .
I actually thought she made many good points today.

[peak_a_bu]

He did tell Phyllis's he wasn't taking it.

[wfreshie2130]

he admitted to phyllis he WAS off his meds but he ended up at the hospital and got his prescription..we saw him take it at the drinking fountain ... the next day his hair was combed back like ^sonny" if he was still off his meds it has been several days it would be REALLY NOTICEABLE at this point

[mamafenocchi]

I disagree. Sonny still wants to save the marriage. That was his last ditch effort to do so. Carly was never interested in "saving" or "fixing" the marriage so she refused.

I disagree, I believe Carly felt that she could salvage her marriage up until the point she got Sonny in bed with Nina. That was the cow that broke the camels back

[Shellyinphx]

In any of her supposed whining I don't recall her ever saying that her marriage was over and that she didn't want to be with Sonny. He crushed that because he couldn't wait to talk to her. He wanted nina more then he wanted to wait

[taws26]

Carly never said her marriage was over until she found Nina in bed with Sonny. She asked for time to think things through -- that is not unreasonable for anyone who is blindsided by a romance their husband is having with another woman. And Sonny would not give her five minutes to think.

Every time Carly asked him a simple question -- did he still want Nina -- his answer was "I want you". That answer is what wrecked their marriage. Clearly he did not have the will to say the simple words, "No, I don't want Nina".

Carly has a right to complain about what happened to her. I believe Nina was doing the exact same thing all over town with everyone she knows - - Britt, Maxie, Liesl, Scott, Ava, Willow, and even Curtis. And, Nina, unlike Carly, truly whines ... wah wah wah ... I never meant for this to happen ... Yee gods, if a divorce will stop that lame lament of Nina's, bring it on.

[lala214]

She said it quite a few times to many ppl. She said there was no marriage to save.

[parker joe]

This was a transparent attempt to live under the same roof as Carly and foster those "family" feels. After which, they can conveniently fall into bed.

[JackieChan]

This is true. It’s actually happened to them before when Michael was a very small child and Morgan was an infant. At the time, he did not intend for them to reunite but it happened. I could see him believing it could happen again. Them living together for their child is how they fell in love the first time.

[Shellyinphx]

It makes perfect sense if you can believe that he's interested in having his family and romancing nina at the same time

[Seashellsbysea]

Bingo!!! My thought exactly. Carly in the mansion and needy Nina in the penthouse. Best of both worlds for slimy old Sonny.

[Shellyinphx]

I love that Carly didn't accuse him of that but it's certainly what I first thought

[AMK]

I think Sonny is taking his medication but he's not well adjusted yet. I was thinking that when they get divorced, Sonny won't be around Carly trying to manipulate her into not going after Nina anymore; she will be free to make up her own mind and maybe this is why he wanted the two of them to stay in the same home to keep tabs on Carly. I'm very disappointed in Carly because she said the the divorce will affect the kids either way, So why let Sonny have everything they both accumulated during their marriage - I'm afraid Nina is going to benefit from all that Carly didn't want to fight for. Sonny is a greedy son-of-b..ch - he didn't want to give Carly the only two things she asked for and although he now agrees to give her what she wants, I think he will want something else and then change his mind if she doesn't agree - hopefully this will happen and it will push Carly into taking everything from him.

[VixensVamp]

I actually wanted to slap Sonny for making that suggestion!

I'm wondering if his medication is strong enough.

[CarnyQueen]

This was a transparent attempt to live under the same roof as Carly and foster those "family" feels. After which, they can conveniently fall into bed.

I thought that too. And also a transparent attempt to put them in a position where he could control her. She isn't going to be dating anyone else if Sonny can watch her at house.

But if she doesn't want to fall back into bed with him, well, they said no romance, so he could go sniffing around for Nina, who would probably be eagerly waiting at the gatehouse.

Carly was smart to shoot that suggestion down.