cajnej

Wow People sure have a problem with Robin.

Rate this Entry
I am unclear as to whether people have a problem with the current storyline of Robin having PPD or that there are many who just cannot stand the character of Robin, which of course they are entitled to do, but the Robin hate at the moment and the number of threads discussing Robin's "whining and winging", that she is lucky to have Patrick, that she is a control freak, that Liz is going to steal her husband, etc, etc.............it is quite staggering.

What I find unusual about it is, Robin generally is not around too many other characters, she does not throw her self at other women's husbands or boyfriends, she mostly is only contained in the bubble of the hospital and home, rarely venturing out to intrude on mob stories and so forth. Suddenly now Robin is being called in to account for supposed misdeeds to Carly ( OMG Carly of all people, such a standup saintly woman) which occurred years ago and the real show stopper that Robin should thank Carly for saving her life at the MC Hostage Crisis. That almost made me fall on the floor and laugh hysterically.

But to each their own and I guess Robin must get under the skin of so many, which is why so many threads have suddenly sprouted up. I believe that many may find the current story of PPD a confronting one. It is not pretty and easy to slot away neatly in a drawer. It is not a great adventure or running romantically from the bad guys and having love on the run, it is by no means as exciting as lying shot on a sofa while people attempt to stitch you up. No this story is a ltttle closer to what real life is and that is possibly what the problem is. Robin is unhappy and sad, confused and full of guilt. Robin had an expectation, just like all new mothers do, that delivering a happy, healthy baby would be the start of all dreams coming true. This was it. The husband, the home, the baby!!! No this is not what is occurring. Instead we get to see some marvellous acting from Kimberly Mc Culllough as she navigates her way through this difficult but very true to life like story. Kimberly is being backed up so well by Jason Thompson as he plays Patrick who is trying so hard but is also at a loss and is helpless about how to face this major problem with his new wife. Somehow, a long and complicated operation on someone's brain must seem like a walk in the park compared to dealing with his wife's ever increasing spiral into despair. I welcome the oppurtunity for this story to be told. It affects so many and while indeed I do know I am watching a Soap Opera, I can appreciate that things that do occur are a reflection of our current times that we live in and often are portrayed as larger than life. I do feel that this is another chance such as discussing people who are affected by bipolar and also the HIV+ story where there is a wonderful way to break down the barriers of peoples ignorance and total lack of understanding about these conditions. I look forward to and agonize with Robin as she finds her way through this extremely difficult period in her life. Bravo to the writers for making sure Robin remains the wonderful and courageous character she has always been to me.

Submit "Wow People sure have a problem with Robin." to Digg Submit "Wow People sure have a problem with Robin." to del.icio.us Submit "Wow People sure have a problem with Robin." to StumbleUpon Submit "Wow People sure have a problem with Robin." to Google

Tags: None Add / Edit Tags
Categories
Uncategorized

Comments

  1. soper's Avatar
    I think people just like to RAG ON SOMEONE.....
    anyone..... it's her turn now!~
    (not by me, though.... she's my favorite
    pretend person female!)
  2. emlem25's Avatar
    Robin's stories have (luckily) usually fallen on the side of more realistic than other characters. If that's a problem, so be it! I like the way Robin is written, the realistic ones to soapy campy ones.

    A great read Roz and I hope it felt good to vent! The work that KMc is doing is outstanding, and JT as supporting, I mean, equally phenomenal. And I'm excited to see what each do with this material. It's a challenge for both, but I know they'll hit it out of the ballpark everytime!
  3. Maxiegirl's Avatar
    Yeah I think you may have put your finger on it. It's a much more realistic storyline than anything else that happens on GH. It could happen in real life to anyone. And life is messy. Robin dreamt about finding the perfect guy, getting married and having a baby. So a lot of people resent her thinking that she's not appreciating it enough or something. But real life is like that. We dream about things and then we get them but we're not always happy when we get everything we wanted. To add to that, Robin has a serious illness it's not that she's just unhappy about giving birth, she has PPD. So I think a lot of them are not giving her enough slack, being too hard on her. It may be too realistic for them. Anyways. I love what you wrote you expressed it much more eloquently that I caould. But I'm glad there are many Robin fans out there like you and Em and Soper and all the other Robin fans out there who think KMc is doing a fantastic job! As is JT for Patrick!
  4. cajnej's Avatar
    Thank you Soper,Em and Maxigirl for reading and commenting on my little blog entry. I have never blogged before and the day I wrote that blog there was almost a 'board blitz" against Robin so it was great to be able to unleash in a place that was not going to offend anyone.
  5. soper's Avatar
    I try to be there for Robin....and Sonny....
    It is better to support her here.... cause they get real mean over there!!!!
  6. sunshine2005's Avatar
    great post Roz.
    hope you don't mind i was peeping at your messages and found out what your screen name means. no wonder i couldn't figure out how to say it.
  7. pjsoap's Avatar
    I've watched Robin since the character's very first day. I liked her as a child & teen but hated the self-righteous adult she became although she has somewhat softened.

    Carly isn't perfect but has never tried to be. Robin gave Carly as good as she got so I didn't see either woman as innocent. Robin should have thanked Carly for helping to save her life during the Metro seige and the hospital epidemic. It wouldn't have killed her to show a bit of humility.

    I too don't like the way she has lately been acting but it is only part of the disorder and KM is, as usual, a wonderful actress. However, Robin has alread had the 'very bad thing happen to even a really good character' with the HIV storyline so it would just be too cruel if she harms/neglects Emma in a way that will either affect the baby forever or result in her death.

    Liking/Disliking one character doesn't mean attacks have to happen on the others. Each should be judged on their own.